Blog

Cameron’s Crusade

Cameron’s Crusade

When it comes to awards season, Avatar might win everything. But has it changed anything?

Related reviews and interviews

So the BAFTA nominations are out, and the predictable contenders are there. The BAFTA members have picked the most solid, experienced runners in the game.

Avatar, that big, brash, undeniably bold movie has confirmed its place as an awards season juggernaut. It cleared up at the Globes, allowing Cameron to earnestly jabber about the power of cinema. I fear we may hear this spiel on an all too regular basis over the coming months, because can anything out there realistically compete with it?

It’s clearing up at the Box Office, and will almost certainly soon overtake Titanic as the highest grossing film of all time. I wouldn’t be surprised if it performed a clean sweep, winning Best Film at the BAFTAs and the Oscars.

I’d love to know how James Cameron really feels about the finished product. He first conceived the idea in 1995. It cost way over $300 million to make, and was in production for most of the last decade.

But has it fundamentally changed the game? Cameron didn’t spend that long with the aim of making a great movie; he wanted to make today’s equivalent of the Star Wars franchise, the next Terminator, the new Aliens.

But the film’s impressive combination of cinematic innovation and precision is consistently let down by its quasi-liberal politics (reckless use of the military for capitalistic gain is bad, apparently) and self-indulgent attempts to construct the Na’vi’s cultural and theological life.

I would love to have seen the conversations the production team had at the outset…

Cameron is sat in a massive, leather-bound chair, drinking the tears of aspirant directors from a whiskey tumbler as a minion massages conditioner into his hair. Cameron wears a troubled expression. A host of eager consiglieres sit, poised and waiting.

Cameron: “So we’ve got this big lovely tree that somehow possesses the souls of the Na’vi’s ancestors, but we don’t have a name.”

Silence.

Slowly, a young-buck from the back pipes up.

Young Buck: “Well, sir, I know this is a pretty left-field idea, sir, and I’m thinking outside the box here, but how about the Tree of Souls?”

Cameron takes a deep breath. His finger slides along the table towards the trap-door button. Everyone shuffles in their seat and looks even more nervous.

Then a smile spreads across his face: “I think we’ve got it, give that lad a Caribbean island.”

The thing I find amazing about Avatar is that for all the innovation and modernism, it is full of old, worn-out action movie tropes. From the psychedelic, tie-die worm-holes that the Avatars go through to reach Pandora (which haven’t changed since the days of Bill and Ted’s Bogus Journey) to the giant walkers that were in the Matrix films, to the grunts continually shouting phrases like “Get some pain.” Avatar is like a shiny new husk hiding the same old dross.

Cameron may very well deserve all the gongs, but he hasn’t changed the game, and for all those Davids who believe in fresh stories and style over substance… Well, Goliath just got bigger.

Thomas Seymour

Printer friendly version Printer friendly version rss icon RSS feed for comments

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

Comments (9)

  • very well written tommy old boy.very good journalism.i still love avatar though.i,m sorry but ido.love geoff

    Written by Geoff White on January 25th, 2010 at 17:43

  • but you cannot beat terminator 2

    Written by Geoff White on January 25th, 2010 at 17:44

  • Interesting, I enjoyed Avatar and i'm hoping this is the future of film. The 3D element was amazing. Well written critique.

    Written by Amy on January 25th, 2010 at 17:48

  • I concur. Very well written piece, and I don't think Avatar deserves to win any more Oscars than Visual Effects i.e. One. I really did enjoy it, in fact fantastically so, and thought that it was somewhat new, something different, but the more I ponder on it the more I realise that it doesn't deserve to be honoured as ground-breaking, except for the vfx.
    If it wins a slew of awards ahead of other, more deserving pictures just because it made a mint at box office, there will be a fair few disappointed faces:- and not just amongst the film-makers.

    Written by @silvar on January 25th, 2010 at 23:16

  • Thanks for your comments. Suffice to say, I also massively enjoyed it. The opening chapter of the film, when Jake is introduced to Pandora, was incredibly cinematic. Genuinely transportive. To give Cameron his dues, I actually felt you started to get quite a strong sense of their relationship in addition to the stunning visuals. But from the attack sequence onwards, I felt the film very rapidly ran out of ideas and lost momentum. Depressingly so, because I wanted to love it. It's one of those films that seems to get worse after seeing it rather than better.

    Written by Tom on January 27th, 2010 at 10:23

  • My mother in Law called last night and said she and a friend had just seen Avatar and she could not stop talking about how wonderful it was. She is 76 years old and said that she was mystified by the special effects of the movie and was glad that it had a message. She was sad to say that she was not proud to be an American for the first time in her life. "We are just a society of heartless money grabbers". I"t wasn't always that way but maybe it was!" No matter what anyone says good or bad about the movie never bet against Mr. James Cameron you will loose.

    Written by Jay wilson on January 27th, 2010 at 17:09

  • Wonderful writing, give this man an Oscar for the review

    Written by R. Polans on January 28th, 2010 at 10:15

  • did you mean substance over style in that last paragraph?

    Written by Tom. G on January 29th, 2010 at 13:43

  • Yeah I did. Shit. Totally defeated my own argument with one small slip.

    Written by Tom on January 29th, 2010 at 14:54

Leave a Reply

You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Follow us on Twitter
latest comments
  • I operate with these dogs and as far as animal behavior goes, I am a strong believer in nurture and instruction....
    Erickson Gran Torino
  • Dissapointing…a bit to much interference from the Disney Suits perhaps?
  • Surely you're not in any way suggesting that Susan Boyle is the love child of Susan Sarandon and Peter Boyle…...
    Anton Bitel Joe