Blog

The Orange/BAFTA Rising Star Awards 2010

The Orange/BAFTA Rising Star Awards 2010

Checking out the runners and riders for this year's next-sure-thing award.

Related reviews and interviews

Elbowing aside the huddled Londoners queuing in the snow for their rations of black bread and vodka, the cineastical press pack descended on BAFTA’s Piccadilly HQ on Tuesday to see the seal officially broken on this year’s UK awards season with the nominations for The Orange Rising Star Award 2010.

The breakfast buffet duly demolished, the assorted eggy-tied celeb journos, directional young film crews and lavender film critics stuffed their pockets with gratis pastries and gathered to hear the shortlist for the sole BAFTA award to be decided on by that barometer of all things good and decent, The Public (if only Orange had taken as much notice of the masses when they replaced the nice posh voicemail lady with that new one who’s far too flipping chummy for our liking. But that’s a different rant altogether).

Happily, and despite the risks associated with allowing the Great Unwashed a say in anything (see: the National Television Awards), in the five years since its inception, the ORSA has proved a spookily accurate oracle when it comes to predicting big things for its winners. James McAvoy’s wiry charm,
the smoky intensity of Eva Green, Noel Clarke’s restless energy and Shia Laboeuf have all been celebrated.

This year’s nominations don’t quite live up to 2009, when the shortlist included not only Clarke but also the phenomenal Michael Fassbender and Rebecca Hall, but there’s enough to twist the melons of many a film fan. They are:

Jesse Eisenberg


Michael Cera was nominated last year, so he was out even if starring in Year One hadn’t already settled his hash. As World Number 2 in the Hesitant Geek stakes, Eisenberg is the go-to guy for 2010.

Nicholas Hoult


Swooning and sighs greeted Hoult’s A Single Man clip, and grown men/women wondered aloud how the wide eyed innocent from About a Boy had turned into a young Robert Redford as styled by Andy Warhol. Fortunately, Hoult was the only nominee with the good grace to actually turn up, so we all got to see that he is still actually the coltish wee lad beloved of Quality Street-wielding aunties everywhere.

Carey Mulligan


The semi-words ‘obv’ and ‘natch’ spring to mind, Mulligan having been last year’s major find in An Education. The only question is whether, after the six months she’s had, there’s any room left on her mantelpiece for another award.

Tahar Rahim


Fortuitous timing for Rahim, whose breakout role in LWLies favourite A Prophet will be seen in the UK this January. The most exciting nomination in the pack, Rahim’s performance has been somewhat overshadowed by his stylish and endlessly quotable director, Jacques Audiard, so a little more T-time wouldn’t go amiss.

Kristen Stewart


Being the most overground of all the nominees isn’t an advantage here but Stewart’s career choices since Into The Wild have been just the right side of populist.

What’s your take? Who’ll win? Or is there someone who isn’t nominated that deserves it more?

Paul Fairclough

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

Comments (6)

  • Have to say, this blog is actually far kinder than the one I would have written. In fairness, this year's nominees aren't *too* bad – Carey Mulligan and Tahar Rahim are absolutely worthy, and Nicholas Hoult is a genuine 'rising' star.

    But by and large, the past nominees and winners of this award have defined publicity seeking bullshit. Jesse Eisenberg is a decent actor, but he was a rising star in 2002 after Roger Dodger, not seven years and a bunch of films later.

    Kristen Stewart is a desperate sop to the fan vote – an awful 'hey, look how inclusive we are by acknowledging the Twilight phenomenon' rather than an honestly offered recognition of outstanding work, which is what it would have been in 2007 after Into The Wild.

    I understand that this is a public vote, but this is a compromised award whose primary motivation is ensuring and rewarding attention rather than honouring great actors.

    Here's a list of past winners:

    2009 – Noel Clarke – 10 years after he started acting and three years after writing Kidulthood.
    2008 – Shia Labeouf – two years after A Guide To Recognising Your Saints when he was already christened the big new Hollywood shit.
    2007 – Eva Green – four years after The Dreamers made her an actual rising star, not an already mainstream star
    2006 – James McAvoy – got no beef with this.

    My point, very simply, is that practically none of these people can in any sensible way be said to be 'rising' stars. It's a toothless award that doesn't have the nuts to take a risk on people who haven't already been ordained as sure fire stars of the future. Compare and contrast with the European Shooting Stars unveiled in Berlin…

    FYI, I got an e-mail asking me to nominate people, so here's my list:

    1. Aaron Johnson (Nowhere Boy)
    2. Riz Ahmed (Shifty)
    3. Carey Mulligan (An Education)
    4. Andrea Riseborough (Mad, Sad & Bad)
    5. Ran Danker (Eyes Wide Open)
    6. Ed Hogg (Bunny and the Bull / White Lightnin')
    7. Lily Cole (Rage, Dr Parnassus)
    8. Andrew Garfield (Dr Parnassus)
    9. Jeremy Renner (The Hurt Locker)
    10. Kim Ok-vin (Thirst)

    Written by Matt Bochenski on January 21st, 2010 at 12:51

  • My sentiments exactly. When this award comes on it's time for a tea break.

    I think it's just Bafta's way of acknowledging today's cinema going yoof but it really is a waste of time.

    Written by Frenchie on January 21st, 2010 at 13:44

  • It's pretty obvious that, given that the winner is determined by public vote, the Twilight fans will vote en masse for Kristen Stewart and she'll win. Definitely not the most deserving (especially when you consider her 'acting' seems to consist solely of twitching and looking bored) but when you get someone with such an intense and loyal fanbase as Stewart it's almost a given that they will win.

    Written by Hannah on January 21st, 2010 at 14:58

  • Not that I'm saying she deserves to win or anything, but Stewart was very good in Adventureland, I thought…
    …and contrary to rumours, Jeremy Renner is hardly a 'rising star' either (he's been winning awards since 2001).

    Written by Anton Bitel on January 21st, 2010 at 15:11

  • Have you seen the trailer for The Runaways? That's all she does.

    Written by Frenchie on January 21st, 2010 at 15:52

Leave a Reply

You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Follow us on Twitter
latest comments
  • I think the relationship between Bad Blake and Tommy Sweet is self-explanatory and has a lot of depth in the film. We...
  • I did actually mention Maya Deren's films, as well as Dali/Bunuel-Un Chien Andalou – for some reason...
    Thom Harris Art On Film
  • A fine piece if you ask me, I think it's got a good amount of depth for the length and plenty of names for...
    Thom Harris Art On Film