Reviews

Black Water

Black Water

Released
January 25 2008
Directed By
David Nerlich, Andrew Traucki
Starring Maeve Dermody, Diana Glenn, Andy Rodoreda

Related reviews and interviews

You can tell from the get go that Black Water is going to be a well-conceived but badly executed thriller. It has aspirations towards The Blair Witch Project and Jaws, but the kind of execution that’s more The Bare Wench Project meets Piranha.

Grace (Diana Glenn), her boyfriend Adam (Andy Rodoreda) and her little sister Lee (Maeve Dermondy) decide to take a river tour while on holiday. After drifting into a mangrove swamp their boat is capsized and they soon realise they’ve been attacked by a crocodile.

As the onslaught of XXXX drinking, casual swearing and Steve Irwin look-a-likey tour guide suggest, Black Water is set in Northern Australia where, according to the opening shot, croc attacks are a regular occurrence. Even so, that hardly warrants the ‘based on a true story’ tag pinned to the film.

With a plot focused almost entirely on the survival of only three characters, it’s not a big ask for Black Water to sustain the tension for a tight 90 minutes. But although the footage of real crocs is an effective choice by co-directors David Nerlich and Andrew Traucki, and the first attack jolts the film to life, it doesn’t leave you on tenterhooks for very long.

The tension quickly dissolves as hunter and hunted play a game of peek-a-boo that turns into a comical farce about as scary as a bush tucker trial. Don’t bother  watching a film that’s essentially Jaws with a crocodile; just watch Jaws instead.

Limara Salt

Anticipation:

Crocodile plus capsized boat equals good time. Anticipation Score

Enjoyment:

Not as good as that bit in Crocodile Dundee. Enjoyment Score

In Retrospect:

A wasted opportunity. In Retrospect Score

Black Water at LOVEFiLM

Comments (1)

  • bollocks,the film was superb

    Written by darren,essex on June 22nd, 2008 at 20:40

Leave a Reply

You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Follow us on Twitter
latest comments
  • Think you will find that the mother of Tati's eldest child was from Prague and held dual nationality Czech and...
  • I'm not sure that I understand these criticisms of Chomet's adaptation. The reading of Tati's...
    Anton Bitel Sylvain Chomet