Reviews

Somewhere review
December 10 2010
Somewhere, curiously and unfortunately, seems destined to be quickly forgotten.
Get ready to get angry. Sofia Coppola’s Golden Lion-winning musing about a self-loathing actor living the high-life of pills, pilseners, cigarettes and pussy while residing in five-star luxury is sure to invoke audience angst.
Set predominantly in a Chateau Marmont hotel room, Stephen Dorff’s Jonny Marco, a commercially successful actor, wallows in self-pity as he manages to string together a life promoting his projects, chasing tail, and dealing with the paranoia parceled with his profile.
The setting necessitates unfair comparisons to Lost in Translation. Unfair because there is no way Dorff can hold our attention in the (many) quiet moments as well as the inimitable Bill Murray. And unfair because the over-treatment of LA onscreen takes away the voyage of discovery on which Coppola carried us in her Japanese-infused masterpiece.
That the film rests so heavily on Dorff’s shoulders is interesting. Coppola could have had her choice of actors in the role, and many cinephiles would be hard-pressed to name a couple of choice Dorff performance. Couldn’t it even be proposed that Dorff’s best trait is often tracked to the ways that he reminds us of other actors?
As the daughter dumped on her dad by a mum who’s finding things too hard to handle, Elle Fanning is the picture of dedicated innocence – she’s adept at whipping up a magical eggs benedict; figure skates with poise; plays a mean game of Guitar Hero; and, finally, manages to deliver a dose of reality to her action star father who is idly allowing life in the fast lane to slow him down.
Fanning is the film’s finest element, fascinating to watch and fabulous at allowing her character to exude naturalism in the overly-manufactured environment.
The film is peppered with industry situations ripe for ridicule, which seem to owe much to Coppola’s own experiences – a faux press junket conference pokes fun at the questions asked by international journalists (made funnier by the fact that they’re so accurate); while a promotional tour of Italy couples incredible accommodations with Marco’s unfortunate appearance on a European dance/awards show.
And yet despite the score by Phoenix, and a soundtrack featuring Foo Fighters, Gwen Stefani, Sting, Bryan Ferry, The Strokes and Kiss, the film serenades its viewers with a slew of suggestive silences. Even the many scenes set in and about Marco’s Ferrari lack the usual radio sounds, Coppola instead focusing in on the growls of the engine as it bounces up and down Sunset Blvd, the Hollywood Hills and the Mojave Desert.
It is in these moments minus-sound that the film finds its footing, forcing us to watch the actors onscreen dealing with everyday banalities amid the mayhem of movie star rituals.
But are these moments enough to set Somewhere apart from other self-aware explorations of the actor’s life, or apart from other Chateau Marmont wanderings? Unlikely, perhaps.
Sofia Coppola’s fourth, curiously and unfortunately, seems destined to be quickly forgotten.
Somewhere (text) by Elliot V. Kotek is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.







My advice: anywhere else.
Written by DavidDaglish on December 10th, 2010 at 20:52
You made some good points, however I still enjoyed the film. It is no Lost In Translation though.
Written by Alex on December 12th, 2010 at 20:26
Kotek, you're too kind. That whole bit with the press junket? She did it already in Lost in Translation. And the interview with the short answers and super-long translation? She did that too.
I think Party Boy was my favourite character, and that's saying a lot.
Written by liz on December 12th, 2010 at 23:02
It's an elitist, arrogant, alluring film about an elitist, arrogant, alluring industry. Coppola speaks of the cult of celebrity with an unmatched clarity, although that may be all she can do. I loved it.
Written by tomseymour on December 13th, 2010 at 13:39
Personally, although I didn't hate Somewhere, I couldn't get past the feeling that Coppola is just making the same observations, only here through lazier metaphors and even more tedious snapshots of celebrity life.
Change the record, already!
Written by Adam on December 13th, 2010 at 13:47
I agree that she's making similar observations to what we saw in Lost in Translation, and the film did feel like a more feminine rendering of Less Than Zero. I find it interesting that so many film journalists are so willing to dismiss the film as an indulgent, smug pean to poor celebrities but would probably do cartwheels for the chance to interview Sofia for ten minutes with six PRs in the room in a posh hotel in Rome. I felt the film was sleek and airy, but it had bite as well. I felt challenged by it…
Written by tomseymour on December 13th, 2010 at 15:32
I really enjoyed the film. I felt the slow pace throughout perfectly represented the slightly monotonous life he was leading in between shoots. However, (SPOILERZZZ) did anyone else find the ending the worst use of metaphor ever? I can see that Coppola has linked the start of the film and the end in that he lives a life of luxury, yet is going round in circles, like the car, and that by walking away from the car at the end he is almost breaking free from that lifestyle, but I just feel the execution was like something you would see in a student film.
Written by Sam on December 17th, 2010 at 11:09
second your final observation
Written by @usedtobethere on January 9th, 2011 at 12:51