Reviews

Tomboy

Tomboy review

Released
September 16 2011

Confirms Sciamma as one of the brightest young voices in contemporary French cinema.

LWLies Recommends

Related reviews and interviews

Having made an international splash with Water Lilies, an assured coming-of-age tale set in the world of synchronised swimming, director Céline Sciamma successfully revisits its themes of adolescence and burgeoning sexuality.

There is definitely something boyish about 10-year-old Laure (Zoé Héran), who has recently moved to a new neighbourhood with her parents and younger sister. It’s summertime and all the other local children are playing outside. Laure’s loneliness is breached when she meets Lisa (Jeanne Disson), who adopts Laure into her circle of friends believing her to be a boy. Laure becomes Michaël, and no sooner has she brought about this ‘transformation’ than she begins joining in with the frequently boisterous activities.

As time passes, Laure’s relationship with Lisa becomes increasingly close, making the ambiguity of her situation ever more complicated. The approaching school term and a number of creeping concerns threaten to shatter Laure/ Michaël’s hard won status and tranquillity.

Rejecting the more traditional second feature route of increased budgets and resources, Sciamma instead adopted a less-is-more approach, scaling back her budget and working with a minimal crew. Creating an incredible sense of intimacy and immediacy – shot over just 20 summer days and in a time period that ran just three months from script completion to the start of production – Sciamma creates a vivid and naturalistic chronicle of childhood, replete with its codes of conduct.

Working from a simple colour palette and drawing on documentary disciplines (the Dardennes are a point of reference), the director forsakes the enclosed world of changing rooms and swimming pools that dominated Water Lilies for a more bucolic environment of lakes and parks.

Sciamma also added subjects surrounding identity and the question of gender to her ingredients, marking Tomboy as a somewhat unique and singular exercise. As with so many aspects of the film, the casting and handling of the almost exclusively non-professional child actors is impeccable. Newcomer Héran is a revelation and the decision to cast her real-life friends adds both to the drama, the camaraderie and the film’s implicit and quite incredible chemistry.

Anticipation:

The follow-up to the highly regarded Water Lilies. Anticipation Score

Enjoyment:

Touching, tender and true. Enjoyment Score4

In Retrospect:

Confirms Sciamma as one of the brightest young voices in contemporary French cinema. In Retrospect Score


Tomboy at LOVEFiLM

Comments (2)

  • "the decision to cast her real-life friends adds both to the drama, the camaraderie and the film’s implicit and quite incredible chemistry."

    No doubt about the chemistry, but what's this about casting her real-life friends? No mention of that in any other article or interview that I've seen.

    Written by Will on September 22nd, 2011 at 17:24

  • Masculinity is a hard act to pull off, but pre-pubescent masculinity is such a fine and narrow ledge between forced and feminine that it’s incredible that it feels so effortless for a ten year old actress. Compare this to Glenn Close and Janet McTeer in Albert Nobbs, and they feel even more like Little Britain characters than they ever did tearing along the beach screaming “I’m a lady…” And they both got Oscar nominations…?

    Written by BackseatDirector on March 9th, 2012 at 00:49

Leave a Reply

You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Follow our Cannes 2012 coverage

LWLies Subscribers Section
Popular on littlewhitelies.co.uk
latest comments
  • It is appropriate time to make a few plans for the longer term and it’s time to be happy. I’ve learn...
    blog submittor Incendies
  • An absolute pulse-pounder, with the best cinematography/soundtrack mixture I have seen in years. A simply thrilling...
    JBottomley The Raid
  • I have fun with, result in I found exactly what I used to be looking for. You have ended my four day lengthy...
    asian brides Robin Williams