Reviews

Wendy and Lucy review
March 6 2009
Kelly Reichardt
Starring Michelle Williams, Wally Dalton, Will Patton
A tender and intimate drama that deftly touches on subjects ranging from America’s class divide to industrialisation and self-identity
TS Eliot once wrote of the French poet Baudelaire that he conjured ‘the poésie des departs, the poésie des salles d’attente’. It wasn’t so much the journey as the liminal spaces between them that captured Baudelaire’s imagination – the possibilities, dreams and regrets that places of departure set before the soul.
In Wendy and Lucy, Kelly Reichardt plays with the flip side: the agony of stasis, and the loneliness that comes from being stuck between a nebulous here and a distant there.
Michelle Williams is Wendy, a young drifter passing through the Pacific Northwest on her way to Alaska. Unlike Christopher McCandless, hero of Sean Penn’s Into The Wild, Wendy is an old-fashioned economic migrant, heading West to find work, not just herself. Lucy is her dog, her only friend and companion, but after their car breaks down, a series of unfortunate twists sees them parted, bringing Wendy’s life of perpetual motion to a sudden, jarring stop.
Working from a John Raymond short story, Reichardt has assembled a tender and intimate drama that deftly touches on subjects ranging from America’s class divide (in which principles are the privilege of the wealthy), to industrialisation and self-identity. “You’re a long way from home, aren’t you?” asks a friendly security guard, but Wendy has no home, no history, no identity.
Reichardt’s great strength as a director is her empathy, and her feeling for America as a bewildering place. Having lived and worked in New York for 20 years, she brings an outsider’s perspective to America’s heartland, and finds it a strange and intimidating place.
That it’s also graced by moments of quiet humanity is central to the appeal of her films. Her characters are vulnerable and imperfect (how you react to Wendy may hinge on whether you think her troubles are self-inflicted), but they are also dignified and real, capable of love and – perhaps the hardest thing of all – self-sacrifice.
Shot almost entirely outdoors in natural light, with understated performances and a soundtrack composed from the noise of an ever-present railroad (as both a metaphor of impermanence and a subtle nod towards Raymond’s original title, Train Choir), like Old Joy, Wendy and Lucy is a film of small details and unassuming craftsmanship. It may be too slight for some, but if you let it get under your skin, it packs a devastating emotional coda.
Wendy and Lucy (text) by Matt Bochenski is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.






DULL as ditchwater, this movie. Waste of frickin' time. Ditch the dog – hop the train, Wendy!
Written by Why Wendy, why? on March 10th, 2009 at 14:06
No! I saw Wendy and Lucy as well and thought it was fantastic. Such a tragic and touching film, plus the dog puts in an excellent performance as Lucy…
Written by Donnie_Smith on March 10th, 2009 at 15:44
what's touching? She's an idiot…
Written by Why Wendy, why? on March 10th, 2009 at 16:55
Don't be so mean, she's just a dog!
Written by Donnie_Smith on March 11th, 2009 at 09:10
Someone pointed out that Wendy has a Christopher robin haircut. Anyone notice too that Wendy's surname is Carroll. Is it just me, or is there something about this lost girl/boy wandering through Amercia's neverland that gives this touching, tragic fable a fairy tale quality?
Written by Catherine on April 15th, 2009 at 19:31